Haha, again, Swanson wanted a blog post so he's getting one. :)
This particular topic has been on my mind since about...midway
through this past semester. It's kinda crazy how my life worked out this past
semester because my classes lined up PERFECTLY and were exactly what I needed
to hear/learn. I took a Student Development class because I needed 2 more
credits and I thought it would be helpful. Its focus was life planning and decision-making.
At the start of the class, I had no clue what my "ideal life plan"
was nor did I think I was that good at making decisions. But this class
helped me more in my personal day-to-day life than any class I’ve taken at BYU.
Anyway, life got busy and I made a list of all these possible blog
post options, back when I would use my blog as an escape for my thoughts. I
revisit one of the topics I wanted to write about awhile ago.
In my Student Development class, we talked about this study done
by a guy named William Perry. His research, "Forms of Ethical
and Intellectual Development in
the College Years," talks about four stages that college students go
through. The four stages Perry identifies are "dualism,"
"multiplicity," "relativism," and
"commitment."
Quick definitions:
Dualism = black/white; right/wrong.
Multiplicity = differences recognized; everyone's opinion is
equal
Relativism = truth depends on evidence; context matters
Commitment = faced with reality, choices are made.
The theory goes that through every year of college, students leave
the dualistic way of thinking and begin to make commitments and life changing
permanent decisions.
However, in my "professional opinion" (that was sarcasm),
I think some people don't grow into these stages and stay dualistic for most of
their life. Maybe I can't judge that right now, seeing as I only deal with
sophomores in college everyday but I think that some of these sophomores I know
right now will not grow up. Let me explain.
I think we all know those people who just can't compromise. It's
not in their nature. They are literally so stuck in their ways that it's their
way or no way. I’ve worked with people like this on school projects and
I’ve found that it’s better not to speak up; just let them voice their opinion
as loudly as they want and not argue.
William Perry would classify these people as “dualistic.” In the past
few months, I have found myself interacting with dualistic people like this on
a daily basis. And I’m not saying it’s
bad thing. It’s great to stick to your
guts and not back down. But there are
some things that can be compromised.
Everyone has good ideas. It
doesn’t always have to be your way or no way.
In addition, these dualistic people don’t always listen when you’re
talking. Is there anything more
frustrating than spending 15 minutes explaining or discussing something and
realizing that the person you’re talking to hasn’t said a thing in return and
is clearly off in their own world? Okay, maybe there are things that are more
frustrating but to me, this bugs me to pieces. I think it's because when I ask how someone is, I honestly want to know and listen. I have many phone
conversations where someone explains their problem and goes through a step by
step discussion of events that led to this problem and I listen.
Then, I take control and try to give
advice. But when a dualistic person is
involved a conversation similar to the one described, they tend to take the topic right back to
them. It can be something simple such as
a person saying, “Oh, I had such a good workout today!” and then the dualistic
individual saying, “I really need to workout, I ate chocolate cake today.”
And I don't think I'm perfect. I just don't see myself as dualistic. In my own mind, I tend to weigh out all the possibilities before I make a judgment. I try to see all sides or try to figure out why someone acts a certain way. But I think I can be dualistic when it comes to some things and I think it's important to stick to your beliefs. My main point of this blog post is don’t be dualistic!
Simple as that. Instead of seeing the
world in black and white, look for the shades of grey and maybe blue or
purple. Next time someone is talking to
you, instead of thinking about yourself, take the time to listen…and really
listen….and listen again…and again. It
can help, I really think it can.
“So many people walk around with a meaningless life. They seem half-asleep, even when they’re busy doing things they think are important. This is because they’re chasing the wrong things.”
— | Morrie Schwartz |